Top Stories

Sino-US climate deal more form than substance?

'UPBEAT SIGNAL': A Chinese couple take their wedding photos by a bridge partially obscured by air pollution, along the bank of the Yangtze River in Wuhan, Hubei province. China and the US have agreed to new limits on carbon emissions.


    Nov 13, 2014

    Sino-US climate deal more form than substance?


    CHINA and the United States agreed yesterday to new limits on carbon emissions starting in 2025, but the pledge by the world's two biggest polluters appears to be more politically significant than substantive.

    As Chinese President Xi Jinping agreed to a date for peak carbon dioxide emissions for the first time and promised to raise the share of zero-carbon energy to 20 per cent of the country's total, US President Barack Obama said his country would cut its own emissions by more than a quarter by 2025.

    At its best, the announcement threw the political weight of the world's two biggest economies behind a new global climate pact to be negotiated in Paris next year.

    But the US has already pledged to cut its carbon emissions by 17 per cent by 2020, and it is not clear if the new proposals will pass a Republican-dominated Congress.

    In a statement, Senate Republican Leader Mitch McConnell branded the new US emission cuts as part of Mr Obama's "ideological war on coal", and said his priority in the new Congress was "easing the burden" of environmental regulations.

    With China still falling short of any absolute target to reduce emissions, Mr Obama could face even more pressure.

    For China, the targets add little to its existing commitments to wean itself off carbon, environmental experts said.

    "The statement is an upbeat signal to motivate other countries, but the timeline China has committed to is not a binding target," said Li Junfeng, an influential Chinese climate policy adviser linked to China's state planning agency, the National Development and Reform Commission.

    The peak date was also in line with forecasts made by several state-backed think-tanks, with the China Academy of Social Sciences saying in a study last week that slowing rates of urbanisation would likely mean that industrial emissions would peak around 2025-2030 and start to fall by 2040.

    US officials said that the commitments, the result of months of dialogue between the two countries, would spur other nations to make pledges and deliver "a shot of momentum" into negotiations for the new global agreement.

    "Today's announcement is the political breakthrough we've been waiting for," said Timothy Wirth, former US undersecretary of state for global affairs and the vice-chairman of the United Nations Foundation. "If the two biggest players on climate are able to get together, from two very different perspectives, the rest of the world can see that it's possible to make real progress," he said in a statement.

    The targets could have been more far-reaching, environmental experts said. "It is a very good sign for both countries and injects strong momentum (into negotiations), but the targets are not ambitious enough," said Tao Wang, climate scholar at the Tsinghua-Carnegie Centre for Global Policy in Beijing.

    China's targets should serve as "the floor and not the ceiling", said Li Shuo, a campaigner with environmental group Greenpeace in Beijing. He said the vague wording of "around 2030" also did not help, and could mean any time between 2027 and 2033.